Jay and Nina have been dating since 2015. And while he did like to keep things private, while visiting The Breakfast Club in 2017, he defended their relationship: “I am in a relationship. I’m in a very happy relationship and that’s where I leave it. I don’t really worry about anything else and that’s it. I think for me, we give so much of ourselves in what we do no matter what side of the industry we’re on so for me…a relationship for me is probably the most important thing that I think two people can have.”